HOME HEATING · COST COMPARISON
Heat pump vs. gas furnace: which costs less to run?
BillMellow Editorial · Updated November 4, 2026

There is no single cheaper heating system for every home. Compare the useful heat you need with your electricity price, gas price and equipment efficiency. This calculator estimates variable energy costs; it is not an equipment quote or a promise of savings.
YOUR RATES · ILLUSTRATIVE STARTING VALUES
Estimate the cost of the same useful heat
Use variable delivered energy prices that include per-unit supply and delivery charges, but leave out monthly fixed fees. Check seasonal efficiency in the equipment documentation; the sample values below are only for demonstrating the math.
- Heat pump
- $—
- Gas furnace
- $—
- Difference
- —
Change an input to compare your scenario.
Example only: 8 MMBtu of useful heat, $0.18/kWh, heat-pump COP 3.0, gas at $1.50/therm and furnace AFUE 95%. The calculator runs in your browser; it does not fetch your utility’s current rates.
How the comparison works
The calculator converts both fuels to a common output: dollars per million Btu of useful heat. For a heat pump, it estimates input electricity as useful heat ÷ COP. For a gas furnace, it estimates input gas as useful heat ÷ AFUE. A therm contains 100,000 Btu, and one kWh contains about 3,412 Btu; the gas price and electricity price are multiplied by the required input energy.
The U.S. Energy Information Administration recommends comparing heating fuels by heat content and considering equipment efficiency, installation, operation and maintenance—not comparing raw dollars per kWh with dollars per therm. Heat-pump performance varies with model and conditions; use the seasonal data for the equipment you are considering.
Which numbers should I use?
- Electricity: use a per-kWh price that reflects the variable energy and delivery charges on your rate schedule. If the rate changes by hour or season, estimate a weighted rate for heating use.
- Gas: use the variable delivered price per therm. If the bill uses CCF, check the utility’s conversion to therms rather than treating the units as identical.
- Heat-pump COP: use seasonal performance at your climate and operating temperatures when available. If you do not know it, try several values to see how sensitive the comparison is.
- Furnace AFUE: use the rating on the equipment label or manufacturer documentation; do not assume every furnace has the same efficiency.
- Useful heat: this is an estimate of heat delivered to the home, not a universal household average. A contractor or energy audit may help estimate the load.
This operating-cost comparison excludes monthly fixed charges, equipment purchase and installation, repairs, maintenance, financing, backup heat and changes in comfort. It does not determine what equipment your home needs. The DOE summarizes heat-pump types and their use in homes in its heat-pump guide.
Estimating whole-home heating? Our guide to heating costs for a 1,500-square-foot house explains how to use your fuel bills, weather and home details; square footage alone cannot predict the cost.
Looking into a winter bill increase? See how to compare winter usage and charges. To review your actual electricity statements, use the two-bill comparison.
Compare delivered heat, not appliance labels alone
A heat pump and a gas furnace use different energy sources, so comparing their equipment ratings by themselves can be misleading. Estimate the heat needed by the home for the same period, then account for the system’s seasonal performance and the price of each fuel. A heat pump’s efficiency changes with outdoor conditions and equipment type; a gas system’s delivered heat depends on its efficiency and the gas rate. Use manufacturer data or a qualified assessment for the actual equipment rather than assuming one national efficiency.
Separate variable energy cost from fixed monthly charges. If a household keeps a gas account for cooking or water heating, the gas customer charge may remain even when space heating changes. Likewise, an electric service charge may exist regardless of heat-pump use. Show one estimate with charges that would actually disappear and another with charges that remain.
Build a realistic seasonal comparison
Use bills from comparable heating periods where possible and normalize for billing days. Record electricity kWh, therms or other fuel units, weather, thermostat schedule, and any supplemental resistance heat. A milder winter, a different occupancy schedule, or a new insulation project can make one year look more efficient even if the equipment did not change.
Include purchase and installation costs, maintenance, electrical or gas work, incentives, and financing separately from monthly operating cost. A lower projected energy bill does not by itself establish a shorter payback. For a decision, ask a contractor to document assumptions and compare options using your utility rates and home conditions.
Sources: EIA: How to compare the cost of heating fuels · DOE: Heat pumps